84-year-old man missing Nancy Guthrie Concern continues as online discussion of what may have happened intensified as investigators pursued leads. A retired federal investigator is now publicly questioning whether the incident was a burglary.
Jennifer Cofindaffer, retiree FBI agentshared a detailed post about X questioning the burglary theory. She believes there are several factors that are inconsistent with typical break-in patterns.
“Is this a run-of-the-mill burglary of your home? I don’t think so,” Coffendaver wrote, noting factors she considered unusual.
Among her observations: the person seen near the residence was carrying a full backpack, the residence was set back from the street and had surveillance cameras, and most burglaries occurred during the day rather than late at night.
She also described the person caught on the porch as being unusually casual.
“Burglars don’t steal from an 84-year-old grandmother. They steal,” she wrote, noting that no property appeared to have been stolen.
Authorities have not confirmed Coffendaver’s claims, and investigators have not publicly revealed a clear motive.
Online reaction
Cofindafer’s post sparked heated debate online. One commenter claimed, “It’s outrageous in my opinion that Savannah and her husband are hiding the truth!” Another speculated, “Not a thief. He’s a repairman or part of a cleanup crew. That’s why he has a full backpack.”
Others have refuted this theory. One user wrote: “You could totally commit a burglary if you were wearing a full backpack. That backpack also included other bags for carrying items… which makes total sense.” Another questioned the motivation, asking: “But Jennifer, one has to ask what is the end game?”
Another reply read: “But yes, I think she might be dead.”
Also read: Nancy Guthrie case update: Trump, Pima County police issue urgent plea; ‘Is she still alive?’
Sheriff says family members are not suspects
The case also reignited speculation about Guthrie’s daughter Anne Guthrie and son-in-law Tommaso Sione. Their names resurfaced after a viral post claimed they were her “official caregivers.”
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos said no family members are considered suspects.
Sione was one of the last people to see Guthrie, reportedly walking her home after dinner the night she disappeared. Her family reported her missing on February 1.
As the search enters its third week, officials reiterated that the investigation remains ongoing. Officials continue to encourage the public to rely on verified updates and submit credible tips as the investigation progresses.
