Kayla Noel Day: Alleged social media profile surfaces amid heat on Nancy Guthrie’s ‘niece’; ‘likes to stab things’

One person claimed on However, there are no official records linking Day to Guthrie. Court records also don’t show any information about the arrest. Channel 2 Now reported Day’s arrest, along with the arrest of a man named Luke Anthony Daley. HT.com could not verify the report or the social media claims.

ALSO READ | The Nancy Guthrie Case: What is Investigative Genealogy? Tactics tried by police helped catch Brian Koberg

“Tattoo artists and piercing artists both wear black gloves…According to KAYLA, she likes getting things tattooed, judging by her Kaystabzthingz account on Tik Tok!!!”, said one person famous The person shared a post that shared Day’s alleged Facebook and TikTok profiles.

Another commented: “She’s also wearing black gloves #kayladay, who was arrested on drug charges on February 12 last year and now-detained boyfriend Luke Daley’s house was raided on February 13 and Zach 4 took photos of his Range Rover.” HT.com cannot verify the authenticity of these claims.

“Kayla Noel Day’s social media pages have all been taken down,” another person noted.

Some even speculated whether Guthrie’s daughter, “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie, was speaking to Day when she posted a video message seeking her mother’s return. In the videos, Savannah is usually seen alongside siblings Annie and Karen. “have Savannah GuthrieSocial media posts about Nancy Guthrie’s kidnapping that have been her speaking directly to Kayla Day? ” ask.

Grok, meanwhile, fact-checked user links that might have pointed to Guthrie. “According to social media reports and limited news, Kayla Noel Day is a resident of Tucson, Arizona who was allegedly involved in Luke Daley’s 2025 drug trafficking case (arrested on fentanyl-related charges). Some accounts claim she is the niece of missing woman Nancy Guthrie, but the FBI Official sources like the Pima County Sheriff’s Department have not confirmed this, nor have they confirmed any recent arrests related to the case — the detainees have been released.”